Fayetteville Menu

View and download a PDF of our menu


Bowl Of Society Fries   $6.00   seasoned fries w/ homemade ketchup & your choice of one dipping sauce: roasted garlic mayo, horseradish mayo, honey mustard, french onion dip or 1,000 island

Each additional sauce $.75

Pimento Cheese Fries   $7.00   seasoned fries topped w/ melted homemade pimento cheese.  Try them loaded: w/ jalapeno & crumbled bacon $9.00

Society Chips & Dip   $4.50   crispy, crunchy chips seasoned w/ Society Magic Powder, served w/ creamy homemade french onion dip


Served w/ Society Chips & homemade pickle

McKinley   $10.00   spiced homemade meatloaf, chipotle-bacon jam, 1,000 island & crispy onions on toasted sourdough

Lafayette   $11.50   fried chicken cutlet, ham, swiss, blue cheese spread & honey mustard on a toasted brioche bun

Ulysses   $10.00   roasted pork loin, peach jam, swiss & greens on a toasted baguette

Washington   $10.00   ham, white cheddar, thinly sliced green apple, roasted garlic mayo & greens on a toasted baguette   

Polk   $10.50   roasted chicken cutlet, chipotle-bacon jam, roasted garlic mayo, pickles & LTO on a toasted brioche bun  

Kennedy   $10.00   roasted pork loin, ham, pickles, swiss, roasted garlic mayo & mustard on a toasted baguette

Eisenhower   $11.00   seared mortadella, ham, cherry peppers, provolone, roasted garlic mayo, red wine vinaigrette & LTO on a toasted baguette

Quincy   $10.50   seared roast beef, balsamic onions, roasted garlic mayo & pepperjack on a toasted baguette

Truman   $10.00   turkey, peach jam, blue cheese spread & crispy onions on a toasted baguette 

Churchill   $9.50   swiss, provolone, white cheddar, spinach & oven dried tomatoes on toasted sourdough

Hoover   $10.50   fried chicken cutlet, honey butter, swiss, pickles & greens on a toasted brioche bun 

Fillmore   $9.00   fried eggplant, cherry peppers, onions, provolone, roasted garlic mayo & greens on a toasted baguette    Substitute Fried Chicken Add $2.00

Jefferson   $11.00   seared roast beef, crumbled bacon, horseradish mayo, white cheddar & LTO on a toasted baguette

Garfield   $9.00   fried eggplant, homemade marinara & provolone on a toasted baguette Substitute Fried Chicken Add $2.00

Lincoln   $10.00   exercise your freedom of choice.   Choose One Meat: turkey, roast beef, ham, or roasted pork loin;  Choose One Cheese: provolone, white cheddar, swiss, pepperjack or aged American;  Spreads: horseradish mayo, roasted garlic mayo, mustard, honey mustard or 1,000 island.  Vegetables:  lettuce, tomato, onion, pickles 

LTO = lettuce, tomato & onion


1/3 lb all natural beef patty; served on a toasted brioche bun with Society Fries & homemade pickle 

Lark   $11.50   crumbled bacon, 1,000 island, over-easy egg, onions & pepperjack

Eagle   $14.00   seared mortadella, over-easy egg, roasted garlic mayo, pickles, crispy onions & aged American cheese

Velvet   $11.50   crumbled bacon, french onion dip, balsamic onions & swiss

Rawhide   $11.50   jalapeno peppers, over-easy egg, roasted garlic mayo & pepperjack

Dynamo   $11.00   crumbled bacon, blue cheese spread, oven dried tomatoes & crispy onions

General   $10.00   1,000 island, pickles, LTO & your choice of cheese: provolone, white cheddar, swiss, pepperjack or aged American

LTO = lettuce, tomato & onion


All Kid’wiches are served on sourdough bread with a side of green apple slices. Sub fries for apple: add $1.  For children 12 and under, please.

Toasted PB&J   $5.00   a favorite among our young society members

Toasted Cheese   $5.50   provolone & aged American melted to cheesy perfection

Fried Chicken Strips   $5.50   w/ honey mustard sauce

Meat & Cheese   $5.50   plain, choose ham or turkey, choose provolone or aged American

Kid’s Cheeseburger  $7.00   plain, choose provolone or aged American, served on a toasted brioche bun


Dressing options:  green goddess / balsamic vinaigrette / honey mustard / red wine vinaigrette / 1,000 island

Lucy   $5.00/$9.00   baby spinach w/ green apple slices, spiced cashews, red onions & blue cheese tossed in our green goddess dressing

Martha   $3.50/$6.00   mixed greens w/ cucumber, tomato & red onions tossed in our green goddess dressing or balsamic vinaigrette

Eleanor   $5.00/$9.00   our Martha salad w/ crumbled bacon, hard boiled egg & blue cheese tossed in our green goddess dressing     

Dolley  $5.00/$9.00   mixed greens w/ sliced turkey, oven dried tomatoes, blue cheese & red onions tossed in our balsamic vinaigrette

Orzo Salad   $3.00/$4.50   pasta salad w/ cucumber, parsley, mint, lemon & extra virgin olive oil

Fried eggplant, fried or roasted chicken cutlet- add $3.00.   

Hard boiled egg- add $1.50


All soups are made in house 

Society Spinach Bisque   $3.50/$5.00   a savory blend of spinach, cream & spices

Soup of the Moment   $4.00/$5.50   inspired by the season’s ingredients


All desserts are made in house 

Key Lime Pie   $4.50   w/ cashew-graham cracker crust & homemade whipped cream

Salted Caramel Chocolate Tart   $4.50   decadent chocolate & salted caramel on a graham cracker crust

Beer & Cider

Our beer and cider offerings change due to seasonality and availability. Click below to see our current selection.

current selection


M-F / 4-6pm
Enjoy $1 off Drafts & Wine,
$2 off Starters

what to drink

Wine   $4.50  Red or White wine; house pour

Soda   $2.25  All-natural; variety of flavors available  

Iced Tea & Lemonade   $2.25  All-natural; variety of flavors available

Coffee   $2.25  Larry’s Beans coffee, from Raleigh, NC


We source all-natural products, free of additives or fillers, providing you with delicious, homemade food.